Burly-
I did a long hard search on winches. I ended up going with a company called ENGO that was started by a former Mile Marker winch employee. These things stood up to a hella test done by and offroad magazine shootout. I ended up buying a 10,000 lb and it has been awesome. Here is the link I bought it from- which is cheaper than you can get it from the ENGO site itself!
ENGO Winches - Save Up to 30% and Free Shipping | 4WheelOnline.com
I think mine was like $340 shipped to my door for a 10K winch! I love it! Right now that same winch is $299 with free shipping!
Aaron